Much ado about chemistry, New York Knicks critics too critical


The New York Knicks appear to be the hottest topic these days; better said, their underwhelming lack of progression since the inclusion of Carmelo Anthony seems to be the debate of many hoop discussions. Not much of a debate, really. We’ve heard them all: Are these guys good enough? Will they be competing for a seventh (or eighth) seed in the playoffs again this season? Will the re-signing of Raymond Felton give Amar’e Stoudemire his identity back? The answers are forthcoming, but until that time, I would like the peanut gallery to keep it quiet, or at least discuss something else.

Being from Carolina, I have unbound respect for Raymond Felton. The fact that he excelled on the basketball court for the University of North Carloina-Chapel Hill (2005 NCAA National Champions) just makes that respect more profound. He’s a streaky guard who has battled with confidence and weight issues, but when motivated, Felton can be a terrific guard.

I enjoyed the Felton and Stoudemire partnership, pre-Melo, although Raymond did struggle early on with the pick-and-roll offense. As soon as he started to pick up what then coach Mike D’Antoni was putting down, Felton pushed the tempo and had many impressive performances for the Knicks. When the trade talking began, I was almost certain that Felton wouldn’t be included in the package… my fingers stayed crossed. Danilo Gallinari, Wilson Chandler, and Timofey Mozgov should’ve been enough for the Denver Nuggets. They weren’t. Felton went to Denver and in exchange for his and the services of the aforementioned hoopsters, the Knicks received Anthony and Chauncey Billups, among others.

Raymond Felton has returned and now we’ll get to see if he can turn that dismal, sometimes stagnant offense around. He’s shed some weight, which stresses the determination to prove his worth once again to New York and the Knicks organization. Shipping him off was erroneous, but that’s all in the past. Raymond Felton, Iman Shumpert, and Jason Kidd give the Knicks three reliable options at guard.

Stephon Marbury wasn’t wrong in his statements regarding the inadequate play of the Knicks’ star duo of Amar’e Stoudemire and Carmelo Anthony. When asked if he thought Amar’e and Melo could flourish together, Steph firmly replied, “Nope.” That said, he wasn’t much of a game-changing, team player himself during his time as a Knick. Quite the opposite, actually. A major disturbance and a selfish primadonna was Marbury. Let’s also not forget that Steph was on the 2008 New York Knicks squad (coached by Isaiah Thomas) that has been considered one of the worst teams in professional sports history.

Time will tell on whether or not these guys can muster results as a unit. Again, the acquisition of Felton and Jason Kidd are both conducive for the Knicks. Marcus Camby is returning to New York for a second stint as well. The soon to be over-the-hill Kurt Thomas has also been acquired by the Knicks. This one raised a few eyebrows, including my own, but again, let’s not judge, and let’s muffle the chatter, for we won’t know anything until we actually get to see the finished product in action.

The following two tabs change content below.

Marcus Middleton

Born, but not raised, in Goldsboro, North Carolina, this slender, 6"2 hoops writer has been dedicated to the game for as long as he can remember (and his memory serves him well). Not just the game itself, but how the image of the league (and of course, the players) is perceived by both the fans and the haters breathes life into his prose. There's much to say about how the game is perceived today as opposed to the good ol' days when egos and narcissistic, megalomaniacal behavior were the exception rather than the rule.


  1. Marbury reminds me of a girl that can’t get over being kicked to the curb. Just can’t let it go. He’s a star in China because HE couldn’t mesh with anyone so take what he says the same way you would a scorned woman. I like Felton, he’s a true point guard.He fell off the past couple of seasons because he was truly broken up getting traded from N.Y. where he thought he had found a home.He hasn’t been motivated since. A good point guard should be able to fix the cohesion between the stars. The stars just need to realize two [go to] guys is better than one. I also have confidence in the Hakeem tutoring. I think the team will be just fine. Not championship fine but dangerous fine.

    •  @knickfan212 I think Felton thrives in an up-tempo offense like he played at UNC and with D’Antoni. In his other spots, they walked the ball up (thanks, Larry Brown) and he just fell out of synch. I don’t know how he’s going to do in this offense where it’s not fluid and Melo ball-stops. The pieces, while talented, just don’t seem like they fit. But, we’ll see. – DV

Leave A Reply

  • Masthead

    Frankie Lloyd, Editor-in-Chief
    Aaron Lanton, Managing Editor

    Sandy Dover, Senior Editor
    TJ Macias, Editor
    Sonny Giuliano, Editor
    Karzan Sulaivany, Soccer Editor

    Dennis Velasco, Publisher

    For more information, hit us up: info AT ballermindframe DOT com.

    Write with us!